How Are Trails Rated? | Hikers University

Navigating trail ratings made easy! Discover our expert insights to plan the best hikes tailored to your skills and preferences.

Hiking trails are rated on a scale of difficulty, taking into consideration factors such as elevation gain, distance, terrain, and technical challenges. Various rating systems exist, but understanding the general principles behind them will help you evaluate the difficulty of any given trail.

With a deep-rooted passion for hiking and years of experience exploring diverse trails worldwide, my expertise in trail rating is unwavering. I've meticulously studied the intricate systems used to evaluate trails, from the well-known difficulty ratings to the nuanced factors that impact a hiker's experience. As such, I’ll demystify the trail rating process, providing you with a comprehensive guide that empowers you to select hikes perfectly tailored to your needs.

Table of contents


How Are Trails Rated

When hiking and exploring the great outdoors, understanding the rating systems for trails is essential to ensure a safe and enjoyable experience. We’ll elaborate on common rating systems.

Numerical Rating

The numerical rating is a simple way to gauge a trail's level of difficulty. This system assigns a number, typically ranging from 1 (easiest) to 10 (hardest), to indicate how challenging a hike might be.

Factors such as distance, elevation gain, trail conditions, and required technical skills are considered when assigning a numerical rating. For example, a trail with a low rating like 1 or 2 might be a short, flat hike with a well-maintained path, while a hike rated 9 or 10 could involve treacherous terrain, steep climbs, and the need for specialized gear or skills.

Yosemite Decimal System

The Yosemite Decimal System (YDS), established by the Sierra Club, is another popular trail rating system used primarily in the United States. The YDS categorizes trails into five classes based on the technical difficulty of the hike:

  1. Class 1 – Easy hiking on well-maintained trails.
  2. Class 2 – More challenging hiking with possible scrambling and use of hands required for balance.
  3. Class 3 – Climbing with moderate exposure, may require a rope for safety.
  4. Class 4 – Steeper climbing with increased exposure, often requiring a rope, technical gear, and specialized skills.
  5. Class 5 – Technical rock climbing requiring advanced skills, specialized gear, and protective equipment.

Within Class 5, the YDS includes a decimal point followed by a number (e.g., 5.1, 5.2, ..., 5.15) to further distinguish the difficulty of a climb.

Types of Trails

Now, let’s explore the different types of trails and how they are rated.

Hiking Trails

Based on my personal experience, hiking trails are the most common type of trail people encounter. These trails often provide varying distances, inclines, and terrains, catering to a wide range of skill levels. Most hiking trails are marked, maintained, and well-tread, so finding your way is often straightforward.

Understanding the hiking trail difficulty rating system can help you choose trails that align with your skill level and desired experience.

Easy-rated hiking trails are usually short and cover flat terrain, with distances typically less than half a mile to a mile. These trails could be loop trails, allowing you to start and end at the same trailhead, or they could be point-to-point trails, where hikers traverse from one endpoint to another.

A more difficult trail may have steeper inclines, changes in elevation, and rougher terrain, making it suitable for experienced hikers.

Difficult Trails

Difficult trails, often encountered in steep, rocky terrain, provide a more challenging experience for experienced hikers and climbers. These trails can involve natural obstacles, such as boulders, ledges, and narrow pathways, requiring hikers to navigate through sections that may need scrambling or technical climbing moves.

The following table compares the types of trails to help you make informed decisions when planning for hiking adventures:

Hiking Trails Difficult Trails
Short distances Longer distances
Flat terrain Steep, rocky terrain
Loop or point-to-point Often remote
Easy inclines Significant elevation change
Well-marked and maintained Less maintained, sparse markers

Difficulty Levels

When it comes to a hiking project, understanding the rating system for their difficulty levels is crucial for a safe experience as it will help you avoid any risk involved. There are three commonly used classifications, each represented by a unique symbol: the Green Circle, Blue Square, and Black Diamond.

Green Circle

The Green Circle represents the easiest level of hiking trails. These trails are generally less than three miles long, have flat terrain or a slight incline, and are suitable for most people who enjoy walking, including families with children.

Green Circle Trails offers a low-intensity hike where beginners can gain confidence and experience in the outdoors.

Blue Square

Moving a step up in difficulty, trails marked with a Blue Square are suitable for a novice hiker who wants a bit of a challenge during hiking time. These trails tend to be of moderate difficulty, with a numerical rating between 50 and 100 on the U.S. National Park Service scale.

Hikes in this category are at times longer than three miles and feature more varied terrain with inclines that can require some physical effort. Blue Square trails are perfect for those looking to boost their fitness and develop their hiking skills.

Black Diamond

Lastly, the Black Diamond signifies the most challenging and strenuous trails. These hikes are often lengthy, covered in rough terrain, and feature significant elevation changes that can test even experienced hikers.

They demand a high level of physical fitness, proper gear, and knowledge of navigation and trail safety.

Factors Determining Trail Difficulty

When it comes to trail difficulty rating, several factors play a crucial role in determining how challenging a trail might be. Let’s explore some of these factors.

Elevation gain is a significant factor in determining a trail's difficulty. The higher the elevation gain, the more physically demanding a hike can be. For instance, a trail with an elevation gain of 300 feet can be relatively easy, while those with 1,000 to 2,000 feet of elevation gain can be much more challenging.

Trail condition also plays a critical role in trail difficulty ratings. A well-maintained and clearly marked trail is usually easier to navigate than one that features obstacles, uneven terrain, or poorly marked paths.

Additionally, natural barriers such as rivers, stream crossings, trail intersections, snow-covered terrain, rock scrambles, and steep inclines can make a trail more difficult. Some trails may require technical skills, such as rock climbing or scrambling, to overcome these obstacles.

When considering trail difficulty, the total distance of a hike is essential. Longer trails often require more endurance and can be more challenging, especially if they involve additional factors like steep inclines or difficult terrain.

Another relevant factor in determining hiking trail difficulty is elevation. Hiking at high altitudes can be more challenging due to decreased oxygen levels in the air and the potential for altitude sickness. This is why trails at higher elevations are generally considered more difficult than those at lower elevations.

Lastly, steepness and grade are also important when assessing trail difficulty. Steep trails with a higher grade require more exertion and can be tougher for hikers, especially those who are less experienced or not physically prepared for the challenging conditions.

Conversely, trails with a gentle grade are typically easier and more accessible for a wider range of abilities.

Key Takeaways

  • Trail rating considers difficulty levels based on terrain and obstacles.
  • Rating systems often use symbols or colors to indicate trail difficulty.
  • Factors like steepness, technical features, and trail conditions impact ratings.
  • Trails may be rated for hiking, biking, or off-roading, with distinct criteria.
  • Understanding trail ratings is essential for choosing appropriate outdoor adventures.


Peter Brooks

Peter Brooks

I’m a hiker, backpacker, and general outdoor enthusiast. I started hiking out of college while working for the National Forest Service, and have been hiking ever since. I’ve been solo hiking and leading hiking groups for two decades and have completed hundreds of small hikes and some majorones such as the Appalachian Train and the Pacific Crest Trail, and hiked on four continents. I’d love to share some of my insight with you.

Read More About Peter Brooks